Ribbed Metal Butt Plug with Jewel - Shared between 3 guys.

This one’s special.

I picked this up years ago when I was first dipping my toe into anal play. Back then, I kept it completely to myself. It felt taboo, something I wasn’t ready to talk about, especially with the boys. That changed one night.

I was hosting a BBQ, a few drinks turned into a lot and somehow the conversation drifted (as it always does) to sex. One of the guys casually admitted he’d “accidentally” experienced a rimjob the week before… and didn’t hate it. The group split instantly. Half roasting him, half backing him. I stayed quiet. But I was watching. It surprised me who was curious. Who wasn’t as “straight-laced” as they liked to pretend.

Later that night, after a few more drinks, I pulled one mate aside. He’d been one of the more open ones in the conversation. I admitted I had a toy. He didn’t believe me at first and laughed it off. So I showed him. That moment stuck.

About a week later, I get a call. No hello, just: “Bro… you still got that thing you showed me?” He came over nervous, but curious. Said he couldn’t bring himself to buy one, didn’t want anyone finding it. I reassured him, gave him a few tips and sent him on his way with my butt plug. When he brought it back… let’s just say it had clearly been well used.

After that, things shifted.

Another BBQ, more drinks, and the topic came up again. This time, he spoke up and shared that he’d actually tried it. Suddenly, the most “against it” guy in the group had a lot of questions. Curiosity spreads fast in the right environment. That night ended very differently to the last. Barriers dropped and this little toy quietly became the centre of attention.

My more anal-friendly mate jumped in and told our curious friend he had a toy he could borrow. Complete lie. He even doubled down and said he had it there with him at the BBQ.

I just rolled my eyes, already knowing exactly what he was about to do. “Can I just… hold it?” the curious one asked. I remember thinking, this is either going nowhere… or exactly where I think it is. Because he knew where I kept it, my mate casually wandered inside, pretending to grab it from his bag, but really heading straight to my bedside drawer. A minute later, he was back, placing it straight into his hand like it was the most normal thing in the world.

And that’s when everything shifted. He couldn’t take his eyes off it. At some point, almost without realising, his hand drifted, absently fidgeting, distracted. I clocked it straight away.

“Getting turned on, huh?” I said. He snapped out of it, half laughing, half embarrassed, but didn’t deny it. Said there was something about it… the idea of using it on someone else. Watching. That was all the encouragement needed.

“Go on,” I laughed. “Try it out.” My other mate chimed in, just as casually, like it was nothing. “Yeah, if you can handle it. It’s just us three. No homo.” The room shifted. You could feel it. He didn’t say yes. But he didn’t say no either. And that silence said everything. What started as a joke quickly stopped feeling like one. Lines blurred, curiosity took over, and suddenly it wasn’t just talk anymore, it was happening.

My mate kicked off his shoes, dropped his pants, and leaned back on the couch with his legs up in the air. I took the butt plug out of my mates hand, used my spit and started playing with his hole using the butt plug. After a while of him just watching, he finally wanted a turn to use it on one of us. I kicked off my shoes, dropped my pants and got into the same position, giving our mate two holes to choose from.

Eventually, we peer pressured him into using the butt plug on him but on the condition we’d only go only two rivets in with extra lube. He agreed. It was so fucking hot. 3 guys, all no pants on, sharing this butt plug. When we finished up, I came forward and told him that the butt plug was actually mine but if he ever wanted it, he knew where to find it. He took it home that night. And from that point on, things were very different.

From there, it wasn’t just mine anymore. It had a bit of a journey - shared between us, passed around when curiosity got the better of someone. No labels, no pressure, just exploration behind closed doors. We don’t catch up like that much anymore, but this piece… it holds all of that. A reminder of firsts, curiosity, and a few boundaries being quietly rewritten.

Small in size. Big in story.

Serious buyers only. Judgement Free Zone. Respectful communication appreciated. Free, quick and discreet shipping guaranteed. After something specific? Get in touch so we can make it happen!

Secure payment options available: PayPal / EFT / PayID / Cash (if local)

Check out other listings. We've got all types of Male Things Worn including shoes (including sneakers, air maxes, TNs, soccer boots, joggers etc.), socks, hosiery (including thongs, stockings etc.), underwear (including jockstraps, gstrings, briefs etc.), used toys (including dildos, butt plugs, fleshlights etc.).